The holiday season in the U.S. officially begins next week—or last week if we include Diwali. As we gather with friends and family, the logistics of travel, including where we’ll stay when we get to where we’re going, it’s a good time to remind everyone about Home Exchange, an accommodations option that builds community by tendering in the asynchronous hosting of others to earn points as a future guest.
At Coffee & Connections a few months ago, Jean and Terry shared their experiences with both organizations. While TimeBanking revolves around hours of service, Home Exchange uses the same “banking” system to organize homestays. Neither dictates a one-to-one swap (I stay in your house while you stay in mine). To delineate the difference between the two, Jean explains, “I earned points for helping another Our Time Bank member declutter for two hours, and ‘spent’ those points on a ride to the airport for my trip to North Carolina. To stay in a beautiful bungalow in Ashville, I ‘paid’ with points I earned hosting a traveler from Europe via Home Exchange.”
On HomeExchange.com, every listing is assigned a value in "guest points.” Jean doesn't set that rate, and there's no surge pricing for big events. The algorithm weighs factors like location, bedrooms, and square footage. The site's algorithm decided her Santa Monica studio is worth 101 points a night. So when her most recent European guest stayed for two nights over a weekend while she was away, she banked 202 points to spend wherever and whenever she likes.
For instance, Jean, her visiting mom, and two friends are taking over an entire house in Santa Barbara: a sweet two-bedroom with a gorgeous outdoor area. The hosts have even invited them to play the instruments hanging on the wall. "They're so excited to host us," she says. The only cost is the cleaning fee, which the hosts asked them to cover. "I did the math," Jean says, "and if I split it up amongst all of us, we each pay $37 apiece. A recent weekend in Palm Desert worked out to about $25 each.
The site constantly reminds members that a request isn't a transaction. "You are not ordering something off a menu," Jean says. "You are asking somebody if you can stay in their home." She recommends being personable and explaining why you're visiting. Twice, she's hosted married couples whose grown children happen to live nearby. One wrote: "We want to visit our daughter who lives in Santa Monica. We are tired of sleeping on her couch. Save us." They were thrilled to have Jean's "cute little studio" and some privacy.
Membership isn't free. HomeExchange charges an annual fee of around $235, and Jean admits that signing up made her pause: "Am I really gonna do this?" Her Santa Barbara and Palm Desert trips settled the question. "I've already totally made up for that," she says. "Again and again, it's worked out great."
The obvious question is how anyone hands their keys to a stranger. Jean was skeptical, too. She asked a friend who’s a long time Home Exchanger if they’d had any bad experiences. The friend concentrated hard for a few minutes. "Oh, yeah, there was that one time…Oh, no, my mistake, that was Airbnb, so no, actually!”
Members are verified, and like Airbnb, everyone reviews everyone, hosts and guests alike. Jean has found that the reviews cut in her favor. Many of her guests have done 90 or more exchanges, with glowing testimonials from past hosts. "I'm the new kid on the block," she says. "I'm the person they should be worrying about." She’s diligent about collecting reviews of her own. "I want five-star reviews, and I want everyone to review me," she says. "I'm trying to build my credibility on this site."
Some leases and buildings restrict guests, and Santa Monica has strict short-term rental rules. Jean couldn't list her studio on Airbnb for that reason. Before joining Home Exchange, Jean checked with her neighbors. One didn't mind. The other turned out to be a Home Exchanger too. Now she gives them a heads-up before guests arrive and checks in afterward. She sees home exchange differently because no rent changes hands. "It's just like having a friend over," she says. Still, she reminds anyone who’s considering it to check their own lease and local rules.
Before her guests arrive, Jean empties the trash, labels the recycling, and arranges the key handoff. She also made a three-ring binder "as if I was an Airbnb host.” She skips the cleaning fee for her studio and keeps checkout simple. "Strip the bed, put the towels on the floor, take out the trash, lock the door, and don’t forget to put the keys back," she says. "That’s it!”
Houses with pets or gardens can ask visitors to do more housekeeping tasks during their stays. One listing comes with a turtle, a garden guests could harvest, and a litter of newly adopted kittens to feed. For dedicated pet-sitting, Terry introduced TrustedHousesitters.com, a membership site that pairs pet owners with sitters who stay for free in exchange for care. A close friend of hers has used it for more than five years, mostly to find sitters while she travels for work.
Her friend posts a request a month or two ahead, reviews applicants, and only considers those with four- or five-star ratings. Then she calls or writes to the top candidates before choosing. "She's had a fabulous experience," Terry relays. Basic membership costs $149 a year plus $12 per visit, with pricier tiers above that.
For all the talk of points and fees, Jean and Terry kept returning to the feeling of belonging, even as a first time visitor to a place. The appeal goes deeper than savings. "I love that by simply using TimeBanking and Home Exchange, we’re outside of capitalism, supplanted by community,” Jean enthused. “All of us being rewarded for our collective generosity and trust feels impossible sometimes, but when there’s a system based on the laws of friendship, it’s really restorative.”